Domestic Abuse - Women and Children With Brave Hearts
.
The Spider Web. This is an image depicting Isabella about to catch a spider but her attention was diverted to a scene where her neighbor was strangling his wife. This is a ball point drawing on Moleskine ruled notebook.
.
I was going fishing today but I visited Sidney’s Sari-Sari Store (blog) and was sidetracked. Sidney is my favourite photographer of the Philippines. He is Belgian. He is not a professional photo-journalist but he is better than most distinguished photo-journalists. He is observant, objective, has rapport with the people and respectful of the culture. Sidney photographs daily living in the Philippines. Those of you, who want an understanding of what life in the Philippines is, please visit Sidney’s blog. Be courageous and open-minded. The reason why am writing about this topic today is because I visited Sidney’s blog last night and left a very lengthy comment. I did not mean to ramble but it was about a topic close to my heart. This morning he returned my visit and told me that visiting his blog elevates my blood pressure. I smiled. Maybe, maybe not. I love to visit Sidney and I always have a personal opinion about his posts. He is featuring the contrasts between the rich and the poor but an image of a child with a black-eye saddened me. Today I rambled again on his blog:
.
“I don't understand why you would post photographs on a public blog open to the public for comments and then be surprised about people's reactions. An image of a battered child, wife or elderly is not rare in the Philippines. They simply were not photographed for their own dignity. The child is a different matter. This is not to say that I do not condone public discussion of this issue. In fact, it is my greatest and first disappointment with the Philippines as a nation and as a people. Why would a kind, loving and family oriented society remain tolerant of such abuses? It is simply lack of education and the society's acceptance of machismo and the status quo and the church's tolerance of spousal abuse for the sake of upholding marriages.
.
If we all notice, societies with strong religious influence on governments (South and Central America, Moslem nations) this is a prevalent issue. Violence towards children and women are tolerated. These societies SHAME and BLAME the victims rather than punish the perpetrators. That is why hospitals rarely or never treat rape victims, battered wives and battered teen-agers until they are heavily beaten or dying because they feel shame and the care-givers blame them for their conditions. This was the same in the US except women have more rights, (this is one of the greatest achievements of the women's movement). As an Emergency and Trauma nurse in the US I saw abuse victims and was horrified to still hear other care-givers say "she could just leave". .
.
It is very easy to say "Why don't you leave then?" or "Why do you stay married to him?" In a country with no divorce and the church condemning the woman for abandoning her family, or simply told "This is your fate" or "You should please your husband more", this is a difficult task. Battered women and children are simply trapped.
.
I was a student at UP Diliman when an American friend and I were walking along Padre Faura Avenue. A man was beating his wife in public. People just passed by and ignored the incident. We told the Manila Police officer standing in the corner who also observed the incident to stop it. He told us that it was a "private affair." In public! My heart broke. Then I told my parents, especially my Father and my brothers, all gentle non-violent men that if I ever marry, I will never marry a Filipino man not because he may turn out to be abusive but because being a married woman in the Philippines is a trap.
.
I grew up in a very kind and loving family. My Mother, a progressive thinking woman did not tolerate abuses and taught women to be strong. My childhood home was a refuge for our neighbors who were battered by their drunken and insecure husbands every night. It was horrible for a child to hear screams of pain from an adult.
.
I have used too much of your blog space. This is a very sad issue Sidney and it is sad everyday for some Filipino women and children and they (sic) people who love them.”
This was the photograph that saddened me on Sidney’s blog . I hope to earn enough money and someday build a big house in the Philippines that will be a refuge for battered women and children.

24 comments:
ces,count me in on any efforts needed at any time. you have written a powerful post that speaks the truth. you may not know how or when it makes a difference, but i suspect it will.
i am double proud you are my dearest friend.
I am against any form of violence.
In particular violence within a marriage or family cannot be justified. I would never do nothing if I saw a man beating a woman. I put this in practice about a year and a half ago when I witnessed a man being violent towards a woman in the Brussels subway. They were not related, thank God for the woman. She was very thankful for my intervention, I'm very proud I did this. More people should stand up and show that they do not accept violence. So I'm with you, Ces.
Such acts of violence are never right. We need to stand up against it. Thank you for posting the truth about this :).
I too feel strongly the way you do Ces and do my bit to help when needed even in a country like Australia. It is everywhere whether accepted or not. To leave (sometimes with children) is the most difficult thing a women could do but at the same time in my country it is the best thing she would have ever done.
Hi Ces. I came here thru Sidney's blog, and really enjoyed your artworks. I think they're magnificent. I applaud your view and your good intentions for the women and children in the phils.
But I just have to get my view on this:
"I will never marry a Filipino man not because he may turn out to be abusive but because being a married woman in the Philippines is a trap."
I am aware of some husband treating their wives and children as punching bags, but I think these numbers are far too low to have a conclusion that "being a married woman in the Philippines is a trap". I guess it's just too strong word to be said. I know so many married women that would say otherwise, including my wife and mother, and I bet your mother too.
Sorry for the intrusion. Nothing personal and I still think your art is beautiful.
I also think that domestic abuse is (alas) not a problem only in the Philippines. It is also quite widespread in Europe and probably also in the US.
It is something we shouldn't tolerate!
It seems humanity has still a long way to go...
There are still too many cruel and bad people around.
Not really sure it will ever disappear. I agree that women are much better protected against domestic abuse in Europe than in the Philippines.
I work for abused children. Girls assaulted by their fathers, brothers and other relations. What can get worse than that?
Your post made me ramble.
I am deeply touched by this post. Your readers are of course - just like you and me - strongly against violence of any kind. It is sad to see these children and women suffer from this terrible mad machoism. What kind of guy is treating his wife and children that way? Of course it is a very good idea to start a safe house, but it is not the solution of this huge problem. That is in the hands of the government and the church, together with strong women who want and are able to fight for their sisters and their children. But as long as men are in charge.....
and why are men in charge, anyway?
we've talked about this: is it simply because we women are so devoted to our children that we "let" men play at power and by design or intention overlook the more "nurturing" needs of a society, families, women, children?
@KJ: Oh yes, I think that is the greater part of this problem. POWER in connection with other people is simply not a women thing. You and me both live in the modern societies of this world. We, after living for generations in the dark ages kept there by men know now that women are able to do jobs as good or even better than men, that they can do two or more things perfectly at the same time. (Present me the man who can do that too and I will give him a big hug and offer him my gratulations :-0) I hope very much that the women in places like the Philippines will unite and help each other against the men who think that they can do with them ánd those poor children whatever they like.
Did I say 'gratulations'? Of course this has to be 'congratulations'. (My late teacher English Mrs. Fontein is shaking her poor head)
Ouch!
Despite the long post.. thats not the issue.. the most striking line that hit me was "I will never marry a Filipino man not because he may turn out to be abusive but because being a married woman in the Philippines is a trap."
just one word for your heartfelt post.. and too personal for me to share.. but all i can say is ouch!
oh and btw i personally know a place/ house here in manila where they shelter battered women.. although only a minute few know of this place. maybe to avoid being tracked down by the mad men..
KJ, thanks for for your support. I can always count on you.
Pieterbie, I know we have talked about this before. Violence towards women and children is everywhere. Some societies deal with it and others deal with it better than others.
Leah, indeed. Let me say that I have taken care of vicitims of violence here in the US also. Wherever it occurs it is heart breaking. The difference is we have criminalize this behavior.
Anon, leaving is very difficult especially with children. It is more difficult when there is no place to go.
Rey, I know what you mean. It is a very strong statement and it is because I grew up hearing neighbors and seeing women battered. Our house was a refuge and I often wondered why the women returned to their husbands. They had no way out. As I said Filipinos are kind and gentle and domestic violence is not limited to certain countries nor economic status. It's just that Philippine law does not consider this behavior nor the battering of children a criminal act and the church does not condone a woman leaving her family. In fact I do remember hearing educated men and also women say that a vocal and strong woman who will argue with her husband in public deserves to be slapped. The marriage trap statement is purely personal. It was also my sour luck not to meet desirable Filipino men who were gentle, loving and protective like my brothers late honorable Father.
Sidney, yet it is not limited to third world countries. I think everyone knows including the perpetrators that violence is wrong but as long as men believe that they can hit women and children and for that matter women who hit men and children without repercusion, then it will continue.
Gautami, that is truly heartbreaking and utterly unconscionable.
Weineke, I think I knew that addressing my blog readers would be like preaching to the choir. In my Emergency nursing experience, treating victims of abuse were for me the most heart rending experience.
KJ, who in her right mind would want to enter politics?
Weineke, I think it is the individual belief and upbringing of men and women and a society that tolerates and accepts this kind of behavior as "just the ways it is" and wishes one would have luck.
AVS, I hope you did not consider my personal opinion as fact . One certainly does not look forward to being divorced when getting married but when there is no way out to safely and legally walk away from a bad marriage then I find that a sort of trap. I hope that Philippine society in general will consider domestic violence unacceptable, intolerable and consider it a criminal behavior. When a man hits another woman during an argument, he can be prosecuted for assault but when he hits his wife during an argument that is a "private matter"? I know you don't condone this behavior and the majority of Filipinos don't. That the safe way house is not known to many tells me that the perpetrators have the power to pursue their victims who are helpless in such a setting. I know that the incidence of domestic abuse will never be known because women will not report them out of fear. In my hospital experience I never saw women in the ER for such complaints.
Oh, that is heartbreaking ... and I love your strong mom and all her strong and loving kids! My mother-in-law lived in a couple of war zones growing up and as a young student she used to share her lunch each day with a little girl who was homeless in her town. She, too, dreams of a family built to shelter and care for those in need. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and that extraordinary painting (that's the one I hope to hang on my own wall someday ...)
Melissa that painting currently hangs on someone's wall. You may have a chance to see it though :-)
I know Ces. In this modern country here in Wester-Europe we don't deal with it. Women get beaten by their husbands and we turn our heads. We don't want to know. About a year ago I was very ashamed. I took the bus home from the station and sat in the front listening to my personal stereo. Later I learned that a man had hit his wife in the back of the bus and had thrown her out of the back door on to the pavement. I had my music on hard and maybe my eyes closed and I never realized what had happenend. Had I been a witness to this, the guy would have hit the pavement next to his spouse and I would have helped the poor woman back in to the bus.
Thas is my point of view on the matter, I don't take this kind of stuff.
Wow, there is so much to say to this - politically, personally, etc. I'm a bit overwhelmed. It is also a hot topic issue with me.
I realize that other parts of the world have it far worse than in the States, but I'm still not happy with the way it is here. I'm not happy with the way it is anywhere. Women have always been the number one targets for abuse and, most likely, always will be. I'm a huge advocate of self-defense and bearing witness.
A man was slapping a women around and screaming at her in her face right outside my window one night. I called the police and they never showed-up. The couple soon left, but I was still infuriated.
We must fight back, for ourselves and for others. We must send a message that this will NOT be tolerated. I've known many who have suffered, even those who have attempted to intervene. It is too often a no win situation in which the abuser always has the power. I wish I had the answers. If we could only rally women into one large army, change the mindset, then we would really be a force to be reckoned with. But how...one at a time doesn't seem to be enough.
All I know is that my stance is: if you attack me, I will kill you if I have to.
Pieterbie, that is a horrible story. What a heartbreaking incident. What did the others do?
Perriette you and I. I have taken care of so many women in the US who have gone through such horrible ordeal. We need a massive education reform staring with the family. Any form of physical violence be it towards the family pet or the child should not be tolerated. People think that it is necessary to spank children. it has done nothing but make them hardened. Last year I have stopped giving blanket donations to huge charity organizations and instead sent my annual contributions to women's and children's shelter. This is a very big problem that cannot be solved overnight but overtime I hope it will be a thing in the past. Women should stop being self-sacrificing. Startting with little children, we must teach girls to demand respect.
what an eyeopening post Ces! very compelling photos and thoughts. I hope your dreams come true!
Hi Val, this issue really bothers me.
Post a Comment